A large and growing volume of scientific research shows that when someone loses weight through calorie restriction, their basal metabolism (the amount of calories their body naturally burns) plummets.
To help understand this, we can look at the oft-quoted “Calories In - Calories Out” (CICO) equation. The standard advice given to dieters for the last century has been to reduce calories in (eat less), increase calories out (move more), and thereby create a calorie deficit (more calories out than in) leading to weight loss.
This has been the most prevalent dieting strategy and the fundamental basis for the most popular weight loss companies, like Weight Watchers and Noom, for decades. During the time that this approach has been dominant, rates of obesity have skyrocketed. 22.9% of American adults were obese in the late-80s. That number has nearly doubled to reach 42.4% in 2017-2018.
(1)
Why has CICO failed us so dramatically? Because while calorie reduction does work short-term, it wrecks our metabolism medium- and long-term. As we reduce calories in, our basal metabolism adapts, lowering calories out in order to balance the equation. We’re doing the same thing we did at the start of our diet (eating a lot less) and no longer seeing any results because we’re no longer creating a calorie deficit.
The famous Biggest Loser study, based on the hit reality TV show, demonstrates this phenomenon clearly. The study tracked 14 contestants from Season 8 of the show who lost significant weight. Six years after their incredible weight loss transformations, nearly all the contestants had gained back nearly all the weight they had lost, and some were heavier than before.
(2)
Perhaps more importantly, they all now burned many fewer calories than would be expected for someone of their size. That is to say, even though they were back to their starting weights, their metabolisms were significantly slower than when they were at that same weight six years earlier.
So why do weight loss plateaus typically happen? Because when you go on a standard calorie restriction diet, your body will quickly adapt to burn fewer calories and eventually stop your progress.
Cutting calories even further will only accelerate this metabolic slowing!